1. OVERVIEW

[1] This matter concerns a request for review of the ministerial decision # 2102783-1 upholding the Notice of Violation # 7011-20-0333 (Notice) by Mr. Shaheen to the Canada Agricultural Review Tribunal (Tribunal), pursuant to paragraph 13(2)(b) of the Agriculture and Agri-Food Administrative Monetary Penalties Act (AAAMP Act).

[2] On November 25, 2020, following his arrival at the Calgary International Airport, Mr. Shaheen failed to present while allegedly importing a pack of meat. Consequently, the Canada Border Services Agency (Agency) issued him a Notice for violating section 16(1) of the Health of Animals Regulations.

2. PROCEDURAL HISTORY

[3] On December 7, 2020, Mr. Shaheen applied to the Minister of Public Safety and Emergency Preparedness for a review of the Notice #7011-20-0333.

[4] On May 5, 2021, the Minister of Public Safety and Emergency Preparedness sent to Mr. Shaheen the ministerial decision # 2102783-1 upholding the original Notice with the monetary penalty in its full amount of $1 300.

[5] On May 17, 2021, Mr. Shaheen sent to the Tribunal his request for review of the ministerial decision by e-mail. This was received by the Tribunal on the same day.

3. OFFER TO SETTLE

[6] On July 12, 2021, the Tribunal sent letters to the Agency and Mr. Shaheen notifying them that Mr. Shaheen’s request for review was admissible.

[7] On July 20, 2021, the Agency presented a written offer to settle the aforementioned case concerning Mr. Shaheen, offering to replace the Notice originally issued with a penalty of $1 300 to a Notice with warning and no monetary penalty.

[8] Mr. Shaheen communicated his acceptance to this offer via email, received by the Tribunal on July 22, 2021.

[9] As explained in the Agency’s offer to settle, their systems will reflect that a settlement has been reached and confirm the removal of the penalty amount.

[10] Mr. Shaheen must understand that all travelers entering into Canada may be subject to secondary examinations by the Agency, regardless of previous enforcement action.

[11] Furthermore, I wish to reiterate to Mr. Shaheen that the introduction of undeclared food, plant or animal products into Canada can result in serious risk to our plant and animal health and can endanger our food supply, agriculture, economy, environment and even our own wellbeing.

4. THE SETTLEMENT

[12] The Tribunal has the sole and exclusive jurisdiction to hear and determine all questions of fact or law regarding any matter over which it is given jurisdiction under the AAAMP Act or any Act of Parliament, pursuant to section 38(1) of the AAAMP Act.

[13] Moreover, as a court of record, the Tribunal is vested with additional powers to the ones explicitly conferred by its enabling legislation. These powers are available to the Tribunal as they are necessary to fulfill the purpose and objective of the statutory regime created by the legislature. [1] This ensures the enforcement of its orders and other matters necessary to duly exercise its jurisdiction pursuant to section 41(2) of the AAAMP Act.

[14] The Tribunal does not have the explicit authority to replace a Notice with penalty to a Notice without penalty. However, the Tribunal has the jurisdiction by necessary implication and practical necessity to give effect to the settlement agreement as established in Atkinson [2] .

[15] Given these powers provided to me by statute, I agree that the most just and efficient outcome in this case is to amend the Notice with a penalty of $1 300 to a Notice with warning and no monetary penalty.

[16] This settlement agreement constitutes a final settlement of the rights of both parties in relation to CART-2021-BMR-021 and the events which occurred on November 25, 2020.

[17] This settlement should not be cited as a precedent or otherwise relied on except in relation to the current Notice.

5. ORDER

[18] As requested by the parties and pursuant to the powers conferred to me, I confirm, by ORDER, the settlement agreement.

[19] I wish to inform Mr. Shaheen that this Notice is not a criminal offence. After five years, he may apply to the Minister of Public Safety and Emergency Preparedness to have the Notice removed from the records, in accordance with section 23 of the AAAMP Act.

Dated at Ottawa, Ontario, on this 5^th day of August 2021.

Luc Bélanger

Chairperson

Canada Agricultural Review Tribunal